Key Lime Pie Popsicles are basically frozen key lime pie on a stick! Portable pieces of pie. Yes!!! Sweet and tangy, no cook, and only 4 ingredients! I didn’t forget the pie crust!
I put the key lime slice on the inside of the popsicle mold before spooning in the filling. It freezes to the popsicle when unmolded. It easily pulls off just before eating.
I squeezed all 22 of the little key limes but feel free to use it’s larger cousin, the Persian/Tahitian limes which are the most common in the grocery store. It takes fewer limes, they are available all year, and cost less.
Click below to PRINT the recipe.